Grain Coffee: What It Is, How It Tastes and How to Make It

Contents
Grain coffee is a hot drink made from roasted cereal grains, usually barley, sometimes with rye, malt or chicory added. It has no caffeine, very little acidity, and a toasty, malty flavor that’s closer to coffee than you’d expect, though no one will mistake it for an espresso. It’s been a staple in parts of Europe for well over a century and is now sold as a coffee substitute in most health food shops. Below is what it is, what’s actually in it nutritionally, how it compares with a few other substitutes, and how to make some of them at home.
What is Grain Coffee?
Understanding the Basics
Grain coffee, also called cereal coffee, is one of the oldest alternatives to traditional coffee. The grains are roasted until dark, which creates the same kind of browning reactions that give coffee beans their roasted flavor, then ground or turned into an instant powder.
Barley is the most common base. Rye, wheat, malted barley and spelt also turn up, and many blends add roasted chicory root (not a grain, but it adds bitterness) or figs for sweetness. Italy’s caffè d’orzo is pure roasted barley; brands like Caro and Inka blend barley, rye and chicory.
You can find it in two forms. Instant grain coffee dissolves in hot water or milk like instant coffee and is by far the most common. Ground grain coffee is brewed like regular coffee, in a moka pot, French press, drip machine or even an espresso machine, and tends to taste fuller. Italian cafés will make you an orzo in an espresso machine if you ask.
Nutritional Benefits of Grain Coffee
It’s easy to oversell this. A cup of grain coffee is mostly water with a small amount of dissolved roasted grain, so it’s not a significant source of vitamins or minerals. Instant versions contain some soluble fiber and small amounts of minerals like potassium and magnesium, but you’d get far more from eating the grains themselves.
The real advantages are simpler:
- No caffeine. Pure grain coffee is naturally caffeine-free, so you can drink it in the evening.
- Low acidity. It’s much less acidic than coffee, which is why people with a sensitive stomach or reflux often switch to it.
- Some antioxidants. Roasting produces compounds with antioxidant activity, though far less is known about them than about coffee’s.
- Low calorie. Black, a cup has very few calories. What you add is another matter.
Blends that include chicory or dandelion root also bring inulin, a prebiotic fiber that feeds gut bacteria (and can cause gas if you’re sensitive to it).
Most grain coffees are made from barley, rye or wheat, so they contain gluten. If you have celiac disease, look for one specifically labeled gluten-free.
Related: Understanding the Challenges of Regular Coffee
Other Coffee Substitutes Worth Knowing
Grain coffee is usually sold alongside a few other substitutes. Two are roasted roots that often end up in grain blends, and one is a caffeinated tea.
1. Chicory Root Coffee
Chicory root coffee is made from the roasted, ground root of the chicory plant. It’s darker and more bitter than grain coffee, with a woody, slightly nutty taste. It’s caffeine-free and is the most common partner for barley in grain coffee blends.
2. Yerba Mate Tea
Yerba mate is made from the leaves of the Ilex paraguariensis plant and is the national drink of Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay. It’s not a grain and it’s not caffeine-free: a cup has roughly a third to half of the caffeine in a cup of coffee. Some people find it gives a smoother lift than coffee. The taste is grassy, bitter and a bit smoky.
3. Dandelion Root Coffee
Dandelion root coffee is made from roasted, ground dandelion roots. It’s earthy and bitter-sweet, lighter than chicory, and caffeine-free. Like chicory, it’s often mixed with roasted grains.
How to Make Grain Coffee Alternatives at Home
The easiest way to make grain coffee at home is to buy it: a heaping teaspoon of instant barley coffee in a mug of hot water or milk. If you’d rather start from scratch, roasting the roots yourself is a good project.
Recipes for Chicory Root Coffee
- Roast the roots: Scrub the chicory roots well and chop them into small, even pieces (about 1/2 inch). Spread them on a baking sheet and roast at 350°F (175°C) for 30 to 45 minutes, stirring now and then, until they’re dark brown all the way through. Watch the end closely, as they go from brown to burnt quickly.
- Grind: Let them cool completely, then grind in a coffee grinder to a texture like regular ground coffee.
- Brew: Use it like ground coffee in a French press, pour-over or drip machine. Start with about half as much as you’d use for coffee, since chicory is strong.
- Taste and adjust: Expect a woody, nutty flavor with plenty of bitterness. Milk softens it a lot.
Homemade chicory keeps for a few weeks in an airtight jar.
Preparing Yerba Mate Tea
Mate is traditionally drunk from a gourd (also called a mate) through a metal straw with a filter at the bottom, the bombilla. You can also just brew it in a French press. The traditional way:
- Buy fresh mate: Look for a brand that’s well within its date. Old mate tastes flat.
- Heat the water: Aim for 160–180°F (70–80°C). Boiling water makes it harsh and bitter.
- Cure the gourd (optional): A new natural gourd is usually cured before first use, by filling it with mate and hot water and leaving it overnight.
- Fill the gourd: Fill it about two-thirds full of mate, tip it so the leaves pile up on one side, and insert the bombilla into the lower side.
- Pour: Wet the leaves with a little cool water first, then pour the hot water into the hollow next to the pile.
- Sip and refill: Drink it, then top up with hot water. The same leaves will take many refills before they lose their flavor.
Remember that mate contains caffeine, so it’s a swap for coffee’s lift, not a way to cut out stimulants.
DIY Dandelion Root Coffee
The process is the same as for chicory: dig, clean, roast, grind, brew.
- Find clean plants: Only dig dandelions from places you know haven’t been sprayed with herbicide, and away from roadsides. If in doubt, buy the dried root.
- Harvest: The roots are best in autumn or early spring, when they’re fat with stored starch. Dig deep with a garden fork, as the taproots are long and snap easily.
- Roast: Scrub and chop the roots, then roast at around 300–350°F (150–175°C) until they’re dark brown and smell roasty. Small pieces take 30 minutes to an hour.
- Grind: Grind once cool, to the texture of coffee grounds.
- Brew: Simmer a tablespoon per cup in water for about 10 minutes, or use a French press with a longer steep.
- Flavor: Cinnamon, a little nutmeg or a drop of vanilla all work well.
- Serve: It’s good with milk and a little honey, and goes nicely with dark chocolate.
Benefits of Grain Coffee Alternatives
Health Benefits
Most of the case for grain coffee is about what it doesn’t have:
- No caffeine: No jitters, no afternoon crash and no effect on your sleep.
- Low acidity: Gentler on the stomach than coffee, which helps if you get heartburn.
- Some fiber: Instant grain coffee contains a little soluble fiber, and chicory or dandelion blends add inulin.
- Few calories: A good base for a latte that’s lighter than a mocha.
Grain coffee does contain acrylamide, a compound that forms when starchy foods are roasted, as does coffee. The amounts in a normal cup aren’t considered a concern, but it’s one more reason not to treat grain coffee as a health drink. It’s a pleasant, caffeine-free hot drink, and that’s enough.
Taste and Flavor Profile
- Grain coffee: Toasty and malty, a bit like the crust of dark bread, with a mild bitterness. Thinner than coffee. With milk, it’s close to a milky coffee in color and quite comforting.
- Chicory root coffee: Darker and more bitter, woody and nutty, with a caramel-like sweetness underneath.
- Yerba mate: Not coffee-like at all. Grassy, herbal and bitter, sometimes smoky.
- Dandelion root coffee: Earthy, mildly bitter and a little sweet. Lighter than chicory.
Blends that combine these tend to taste better than any one ingredient alone. Barley gives body, chicory gives bitterness, and figs or carob add sweetness.
Related: More on the taste and flavor profile of coffee alternatives
Grain Coffee Alternatives and Wellness
Impact on Energy Levels
- Grain coffee vs. caffeine: Grain coffee won’t give you an energy boost. What it does is remove caffeine from the picture, so you avoid the crash and the sleep disruption. If you’re used to several cups of coffee a day, expect a few days of headaches and tiredness as you adjust. For something that gives a gentler lift without the caffeine crash, look at other options.
- The ritual still helps: A lot of what people miss about coffee is the warm cup and the pause. Grain coffee keeps that, which makes cutting caffeine easier.
Incorporating into a Healthy Lifestyle
The simplest way to start is to replace one cup, usually the afternoon one, which is the one most likely to affect your sleep. A few tips:
- Make it with milk at first: Grain coffee made with hot milk (or oat milk) is the most coffee-like version, and the easiest to get used to.
- Watch the extras: Some instant blends contain added sugar. Check the label.
- Try a few brands: They differ more than you’d think, from very mild barley to strong, bitter chicory blends.
- Check for gluten: Most contain it.
Grain Coffee Alternatives in Different Cultures
Historical and Cultural Significance
Grain coffee spread for the same reasons as chicory: coffee was expensive, and in hard times hard to get. In 19th- and 20th-century Europe, roasted grain drinks were a cheap everyday substitute, and they became especially common during the two World Wars. In Germany, malt coffee earned the nickname “Muckefuck”. In the US, Postum, a roasted wheat and molasses drink, launched in the 1890s and had a loyal following for decades, partly because some religious groups avoid caffeine.
Traditional Uses in Various Regions
Some of these traditions are still going strong:
- In Italy, caffè d’orzo (roasted barley) is a normal café order, especially for children and people avoiding caffeine. Poland, Germany and other parts of Central and Eastern Europe have their own grain coffee brands and long habits of drinking them.
- In Japan and Korea, roasted barley tea (mugicha and boricha) is an everyday drink, served cold in summer and hot in winter. It’s lighter than grain coffee but tastes similar.
- In parts of Latin America, drinks made from roasted barley or corn are sold as coffee substitutes and have a long history as cheaper alternatives to coffee.
Should You Try Grain Coffee?
If you want a hot, caffeine-free drink that’s easy on the stomach and still feels a bit like coffee, grain coffee is worth a try. Start with an instant barley or barley-chicory blend, made with hot milk, and use it to replace your afternoon cup. Don’t expect it to taste like coffee, and don’t expect it to transform your health. Just think of it as a good drink in its own right, and judge it after a week.


