Herbal Based Teas11 min read

10 Healthy Tea Substitutes for Coffee

Cups of Teas Substitutes for Coffee

Tea is the easiest swap for coffee. It’s cheap, it’s everywhere, and you can pick exactly how much caffeine you want, from a strong black tea to an herbal tea with none at all. If coffee gives you the jitters or keeps you up, one of the teas below will probably suit you better. And if you want something that isn’t tea at all, we cover plenty of other alternatives to coffee elsewhere on the site.

What Are Tea Substitutes for Coffee?

Any tea you drink in place of coffee counts. People switch for different reasons: less caffeine, a gentler stomach, or just being bored of the same cup every morning. The options split into two groups. “True” teas (black, green, white, oolong) come from the Camellia sinensis plant and contain caffeine. Herbal and fruit teas are made from other plants and are usually caffeine-free.

Here are the ten we’d look at first:

  • Herbal teas: Herbal teas such as chamomile, peppermint and ginger have no caffeine. Good for the afternoon and evening.
  • Green tea: Matcha, sencha and the rest. Some caffeine, usually less than coffee, and a grassy, sometimes savory taste.
  • White tea: Lightly processed, with a soft, slightly sweet flavor.
  • Black tea: The obvious first step away from coffee. It’s strong and malty and takes milk well.
  • Oolong: Somewhere between green and black, depending on how far the leaves are oxidized.
  • Fruit teas: Dried fruit and hibiscus blends. No caffeine, and they’re good iced.
  • Rooibos: A South African red bush tea. Caffeine-free, naturally sweet and a bit earthy.
  • Yerba mate: A South American drink with real caffeine and a bitter, grassy taste. The closest thing here to a coffee kick.
  • Chai: Black tea simmered with spices and milk. Warming and filling.
  • Floral teas: Jasmine, rose, hibiscus and the like. Fragrant and light.

Health Benefits of Tea Substitutes for Coffee

Tea has been studied a lot, and the overall picture is positive, though most of the evidence is about regular true tea drinkers rather than any single cup.[1]

  • Polyphenols: True teas are full of catechins and flavonoids, plant compounds with antioxidant activity. Many herbal teas contain their own polyphenols too.
  • Digestion: Ginger and peppermint teas are old standbys for an upset stomach, nausea and bloating.
  • Winding down: Chamomile and lavender are traditionally drunk to relax and help with sleep. The evidence is modest, but a caffeine-free cup at night certainly won’t keep you awake.
  • Focus without the spike: Green tea and matcha pair caffeine with L-theanine, an amino acid that many people find takes the edge off. The result tends to feel calmer than coffee.
  • Hydration: Herbal teas are basically flavored water, and even caffeinated tea counts toward your daily fluids.

Don’t expect tea to transform your health. The main win for most people is simply drinking less caffeine than they did with coffee.

Types of Healthy Tea Substitutes for Coffee

Herbal Teas

Herbal teas are infusions of herbs, flowers, roots or spices. The common ones each have a job people use them for:

  • Chamomile: Mild and apple-like. Mostly drunk before bed, and sometimes for an upset stomach or period cramps.
  • Peppermint: Cool and sharp. A popular after-dinner tea for indigestion, and some people reach for it with a headache or a blocked nose. Skip it if you have reflux, since mint can make heartburn worse.
  • Ginger: Hot and spicy. Fresh ginger slices simmered for 10 minutes make a much stronger tea than a bag. It’s widely used for nausea.
  • Lavender: Very floral, so a little goes a long way. Usually blended with chamomile or mint for a calming evening cup.

Green Teas

Green tea is unoxidized tea leaf, so it keeps its fresh, grassy flavor and a lot of its catechins.[2] Sencha is the everyday Japanese style, matcha is the whole leaf ground to powder, and Chinese green teas like Dragon Well are toastier.

  • It’s high in catechins, especially EGCG, which is where most of the research focuses.
  • Some studies link regular green tea drinking with better brain health and heart health, but most of that is observational.
  • Any effect on metabolism or weight is small. Don’t drink it for that.
  • Brew it cooler than black tea, around 160-175°F, for 2-3 minutes. Boiling water makes it bitter.

White Teas

  • White tea is made from young buds and leaves of the tea plant, picked early.
  • It’s the least processed tea: the leaves are withered and dried rather than rolled or heavily oxidized.
  • The cup is pale with a soft, sweet, sometimes honeyed taste.
  • Well-known types are Silver Needle (all buds), White Peony and Shou Mei.
  • It’s often sold as “low caffeine”, but that isn’t reliable. Bud-heavy white teas can have as much caffeine as green tea, so don’t rely on it if you’re sensitive.

Black Teas

Black tea is fully oxidized, which gives it the strongest flavor and the most body of the true teas. A mug has roughly half the caffeine of a mug of brewed coffee, so it’s a sensible halfway point if you’re cutting back. Assam and English breakfast blends are the most coffee-like with milk.

Oolong Teas

Oolong is partly oxidized, so it can taste anything from light and floral (Tieguanyin) to dark and roasty (Da Hong Pao). The roasted ones are worth trying if you miss coffee’s toasty side. Caffeine is moderate, and the leaves stand up to several short steeps.

Fruit Teas

  • Fruit teas are blends of dried fruit pieces, usually with hibiscus or rosehip for color and tartness. No caffeine.
  • Common flavors include:
  • Strawberry and Mango Tea
  • Pineapple and Coconut Tea
  • Citrus Medley Tea
  • They’re good hot, but better iced. Brew double strength and pour it over ice.
  • Check the label: cheaper ones lean on “natural flavoring” more than fruit.

Rooibos Teas

Rooibos comes from a shrub grown only in South Africa’s Cederberg region. It’s caffeine-free and has a sweet, woody flavor that works with milk, which makes it one of the better swaps for people who liked milky coffee.

  • It’s low in tannins, so it doesn’t go bitter if you over-steep it. You can leave the bag in.
  • It contains aspalathin, an antioxidant that’s fairly specific to rooibos. Research on it is early.
  • Green (unfermented) rooibos is also sold. It’s lighter and grassier.
  • Red rooibos with steamed milk and honey makes a “red latte”, a decent caffeine-free stand-in for a latte.

Yerba Mate

Yerba mate is made from the leaves of a South American holly and is drunk all over Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay and southern Brazil. It has real caffeine, often close to a cup of coffee depending on how it’s brewed. Plenty of drinkers find the lift smoother than coffee’s, but that varies. It’s bitter and smoky, so it’s an acquired taste.

Chai Teas

Chai, or masala chai, comes from India. It’s black tea simmered with milk and spices, and it’s one of the most satisfying swaps for a milky coffee because it has the same body and warmth.

  • Ingredients: Black tea, ginger, cardamom, cinnamon, cloves and black pepper are the usual mix, though every household has its own.
  • Health angle: Ginger and cinnamon have some anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties. In the amounts in a cup of chai, think of them as flavor first.
  • In India: Chai is everywhere, sold from street stalls and offered to guests as a matter of course.
  • Making it: Simmer the spices in water for a few minutes, add the tea and milk, bring it back up, then strain. Instant chai mixes and syrups are fine but much sweeter. Chai still has caffeine from the black tea, so look for rooibos chai if you want none.

Floral Teas

Floral teas use flowers either on their own (chamomile, hibiscus, butterfly pea) or to scent tea leaves (jasmine green tea). They’re light and fragrant and won’t satisfy a craving for something strong, but they’re pleasant in the afternoon.

  • Jasmine tea is green tea scented with jasmine blossoms, so it has caffeine. Most other floral teas don’t.
  • Chamomile and lavender are the usual choices for relaxing.
  • Hibiscus is tart and deep red. Some studies suggest it may lower blood pressure slightly, so check with your doctor if you’re on blood pressure medication.
  • Rose and chamomile are traditionally drunk after meals for digestion.

What Coffee-Like Tea Exist?

No tea really tastes like coffee, but a few come close in feel. One such tea variety is Yerba Mate, made from the leaves of Ilex paraguariensis. It’s bold, earthy and bitter, and it has enough caffeine to replace a morning coffee. Roasted teas like Japanese hojicha and dark-roasted oolong also have that toasty, roasted edge, with less caffeine. And if you take your coffee with milk, a strong Assam with milk is about as close as tea gets.

How to Choose the Right Tea Substitute for Coffee

Three questions narrow it down quickly:

  • How much caffeine do you want? If you want to keep most of it, go with yerba mate or black tea. For less, try green, white or oolong. For none, choose herbal, rooibos or fruit.
  • What did you like about coffee? If it was the bitterness and roast, try roasted oolong, hojicha or mate. If it was a milky, comforting drink, go for chai or rooibos with milk. If you just want something hot to hold, nearly any herbal tea will do.
  • Any health reasons? Peppermint can aggravate reflux. Hibiscus can interact with blood pressure medication. If you’re pregnant, check which herbal teas are considered safe before drinking them daily.

Making the Switch: Tips for Transitioning from Coffee to Tea

Don’t quit coffee overnight unless you want a headache for three days. Replace one cup at a time, starting with the afternoon one, and give each change a week. Black tea or mate in the morning keeps enough caffeine in the system to soften withdrawal.

Expect the first few cups to taste thin. Tea doesn’t have coffee’s body or bitterness, and your palate takes a couple of weeks to adjust. Try a few kinds before you decide you don’t like tea; most people who say that have only had a bag steeped too long in boiling water.

It also helps to keep the ritual. If you liked grinding beans and using a French press, use loose-leaf tea and a teapot. Same habit, different drink.

Related: Read my guide on how to transition from regular coffee to herbal coffee

Best Practices for Brewing and Enjoying Tea

Most bad tea is badly brewed tea. Too hot or too long and it turns bitter. The basics:

  • Use fresh water and decent tea. Loose leaf is usually better than dusty supermarket bags, but good bags exist.
  • Match the temperature to the tea: boiling for black, herbal and rooibos; around 175-185°F for green, white and oolong.
  • Watch the time. Black tea 3-5 minutes, green 2-3, herbal 5-7. Rooibos and most herbals won’t go bitter if you leave them longer.
  • If your tap water is hard or heavily chlorinated, filtered water makes a noticeable difference.
  • Store tea in an airtight container away from light, heat and strong smells. Green tea goes stale fastest.

Tea Substitutes Recipes and Ideas

Once you have a few teas you like, there’s more to do with them than steep a cup. A few easy ideas:

Matcha works in smoothies and lattes: whisk a teaspoon into a little hot water until smooth, then add steamed milk. Chamomile makes a good bedtime latte with warm milk and honey. Strong chai concentrate keeps in the fridge for several days, so a morning chai latte takes a minute.

Tea also works in food. Fruit teas can be brewed strong and used in popsicles or jelly. Chai spices go into cookies and oatmeal. Rooibos is good for poaching pears or soaking dried fruit for a cake. None of this is complicated: brew the tea strong and use it wherever a recipe calls for water or milk.

Conclusion

If you want the simplest swap, start with black tea or yerba mate in the morning and an herbal tea in the afternoon. Once that feels normal, try green tea, oolong or rooibos and see which you keep coming back to. You’ll drink less caffeine either way, and you might find a tea you like more than the coffee you gave up.

 


Keep reading