Coffee Alternatives5 min read

Healthy Non-Caffeinated Coffee Alternatives

Caffeine-Free Coffee Alternative Cup

If coffee gives you the jitters, makes you anxious or keeps you up at night, the obvious fix is to drop the caffeine. Non-caffeinated coffee alternatives let you keep a hot drink in the morning without it. Some, like chicory and grain coffee, taste a fair bit like coffee. Others, like herbal tea, don’t try to. Here are the main options and how to make them.

What Are Non-Caffeinated Coffee Alternatives?

These are drinks you can have as substitutes for traditional coffee that contain no caffeine. People switch for all sorts of reasons: sleep, anxiety, pregnancy, a sensitive stomach, or just wanting a break from depending on a morning cup. The main groups are:

  • Herbal Teas
  • Chicory Root-Based Drinks
  • Mushroom Coffee
  • Various Grain-Based Beverages

Herbal teas are the easiest to find. The best caffeine-free ones for replacing coffee are:

  • Rooibos Tea
  • Peppermint Tea
  • Chamomile Tea
  • Hibiscus Tea

Rooibos is the most morning-friendly of these herbal teas. It’s sweetish and woody, and it takes milk well. Chamomile is mild and calming, so it’s better suited to the evening. Peppermint is good after meals. Hibiscus is tart, high in antioxidants and good iced.

Chicory root-based drinks come closest to coffee. Roasted chicory root brews dark and bitter, a bit woodier than coffee and with less acid. You can drink it alone or blended with other roasted ingredients like barley, carob or dandelion.

Mushroom coffee needs a warning. It’s made with mushroom extracts such as chaga, reishi or lion’s mane, but many products are mixed with regular coffee and do contain caffeine. Only the ones built on a herbal or root base (not coffee or cacao) are fully caffeine-free, so check the label. The claimed health benefits, like focus and immunity, are mostly based on early research.

Grain-based beverages such as barley and rye coffee are made from roasted grains, brewed or dissolved like instant coffee. They taste toasty and malty, milder than coffee, and some blends add chicory or spices. They contain gluten.

Benefits of Non-Caffeinated Coffee Alternatives

The biggest benefit is the obvious one: no caffeine means no caffeine side effects. Beyond that, the claims get weaker, so here’s what’s realistic:

  • No jitters, racing heart or afternoon crash, and no withdrawal headaches once you’ve made the switch.
  • Better sleep for many people, especially if they used to drink coffee after lunch. You can have these in the evening.
  • Root and grain coffees are lower in acid than coffee, so they’re often easier on people prone to heartburn or reflux.
  • Many contain antioxidants, though not more than coffee itself. Don’t expect a meaningful dose of vitamins or minerals from a brewed cup.
  • They’re generally safe in pregnancy, though some herbs aren’t, so check with your midwife or doctor about specific teas.

Popular Non-Caffeinated Coffee Alternatives

Here’s how the main options compare, depending on what you’re after:

  • Herbal Teas: Chamomile, rooibos and peppermint. Light and soothing. Best if you don’t need your drink to taste like coffee.
  • Chicory Root-Based Drinks: Dark, bitter and earthy. The best choice if you miss the taste of black coffee. The inulin fiber in chicory can cause gas if you’re sensitive.
  • Mushroom Coffee: Earthy and slightly bitter. Only caffeine-free if the label says so, as many blends contain coffee.
  • Grain-Based Beverages: Barley and rye coffee are mild, toasty and nutty. A good choice if you take your coffee with milk, since grain coffee makes a decent latte.
  • Decaf Coffee: Not completely caffeine-free, as a cup still has a few milligrams, but it’s the only option that actually tastes like coffee. A reasonable middle ground if you want the flavor and can tolerate a trace of caffeine.

Making Non-Caffeinated Coffee Alternatives at Home

All of these are easy to make, and most need nothing more than a kettle and a French press or strainer:

  • Herbal Teas: Use about a teaspoon of dried herbs or one bag per cup and steep in just-boiled water for 5 minutes. Rooibos can steep longer without turning bitter. Chamomile, lavender and hibiscus are easy to mix and match: try chamomile with a pinch of lavender in the evening, or hibiscus with a little cinnamon.
  • Chicory Root-Based Drinks: Buy roasted chicory granules (roasting raw roots yourself is possible but a lot of work). Use about 1 tablespoon per 6 ounces of water, brew it like coffee in a French press or drip machine, and start with less than you think: chicory is stronger than coffee for the same amount. A splash of milk smooths it out.
  • Mushroom Coffee: Stir a teaspoon of pure mushroom powder into hot water or brewed chicory. Alternatively, simmer dried chaga chunks in water for 15 minutes or longer. Reishi is very bitter, so start small.
  • Grain-Based Beverages: Instant barley coffee just needs a teaspoon stirred into hot water or milk. Ground grain coffee brews like regular coffee, but it can need a little more per cup and a slightly longer steep.

Once you’ve found a base you like, add cinnamon, cardamom, vanilla or cocoa and see what works.

Conclusion

If you miss the taste of coffee, start with chicory or a chicory-and-grain blend. If you take your coffee with plenty of milk, barley coffee makes the easiest latte. If you just want something warm and calm, rooibos or chamomile will do the job for very little money. Check mushroom coffee labels for caffeine before you buy, and give whatever you choose a week or so. Your taste adjusts faster than you’d expect.

Keep reading