Best Coffee Alternatives: Teas, Matcha, Golden Milk and More

Contents
The best coffee alternatives depend on what you’re trying to get away from. If it’s caffeine, herbal teas, golden milk and roasted herbal coffees like Teeccino are the obvious picks. If you just want a gentler lift, yerba mate and matcha still have caffeine but feel different from a strong mug of coffee. This guide covers the main options, how to make each one, and how to pick between them.
Benefits Of The Best Coffee Alternatives
Related: Read more about coffee substitutes and their benefits
Reducing Caffeine Intake
A moderate amount of caffeine gives most people a useful lift. Too much can cause insomnia, nervousness, restlessness and a racing heart.[1] If that sounds familiar, swapping one or two cups a day is an easy place to start:
- Herbal tea: Chamomile, peppermint and ginger have no caffeine and still give you something hot to hold in the morning.
- Decaf coffee: The closest match if you love the taste and ritual of coffee. It isn’t completely caffeine-free, but it’s close.
- Golden milk: Turmeric and spices in warm milk. No caffeine, and more filling than tea.
- Fruit-infused water: Strawberries, citrus or cucumber in cold water. Not a coffee replacement exactly, but a good habit for the afternoon slump when you’d otherwise reach for another cup.
Health Benefits
Most coffee alternatives aren’t health drinks so much as drinks without the downsides of too much caffeine. That said, a few have real points in their favor:
- Antioxidants: Herbal teas, matcha and roasted roots like chicory and dandelion all contain polyphenols. So does coffee, to be fair.
- Digestion: Ginger and peppermint teas have a long track record for settling the stomach.
- Winding down: Chamomile and lavender are traditional evening teas, and many people find them relaxing.
- Turmeric: Curcumin, the main compound in turmeric, has been studied for anti-inflammatory effects. The amount in a mug of golden milk is small, so treat this as a bonus rather than a reason.
Variety and Flavor
The other benefit is simply variety. Coffee tastes like coffee; the alternatives cover a lot more ground. Yerba mate is grassy and slightly smoky, matcha is savory and a bit bitter, golden milk is earthy and warm, and chicory coffee is the nearest thing to the real taste of coffee.
- Roasted roots and grains (chicory, dandelion, barley) give you the dark, bitter flavor of coffee without the caffeine.
- Teas and lattes like turmeric latte or matcha replace the ritual more than the taste.
- Many of these come from long drinking traditions: mate in South America, matcha in Japan, turmeric milk in India.
Types of Coffee Alternatives
Herbal Teas
Herbal teas are the easiest switch. They’re cheap, caffeine-free and sold everywhere. Chamomile, peppermint and hibiscus are the three most people start with, and they taste very different from each other.
Chamomile Tea
Mild, slightly sweet and apple-like. It’s the classic bedtime tea, and many people drink it to help them relax in the evening.
Peppermint Tea
Cool and sharp from the menthol. It’s a common choice after meals because many people find it settles their stomach.
Hibiscus Tea
Tart and fruity, like cranberry, with a deep red color. Some research suggests it may help lower blood pressure slightly. It’s also good iced.
Yerba Mate
Yerba mate is made from the leaves of Ilex paraguariensis, a holly native to South America. It tastes grassy and earthy, a bit like strong green tea with a smoky edge. It does contain caffeine, often somewhere between a cup of tea and a cup of coffee depending on how you brew it, so it’s a step down rather than a clean break. Many drinkers say the lift feels smoother than coffee’s.
Matcha
Matcha is green tea ground into a fine powder, so you drink the whole leaf instead of an infusion. It’s bright green, savory and slightly bitter. It has caffeine, plus L-theanine, an amino acid that many people find takes the edge off the caffeine. That combination is why matcha drinkers often describe a calmer, steadier kind of alertness.
Golden Milk
Golden milk (turmeric milk) is warm milk with turmeric, cinnamon, ginger and black pepper. It’s comforting, mildly spicy and has no caffeine. It works best as an afternoon or evening drink, especially in winter. The pepper is there for a reason: it helps your body absorb the curcumin in turmeric. The recipe is further down.
How to Prepare the Best Coffee Substitute
Brewing Herbal Teas
Pour just-boiled water over the herbs or tea bag, cover the cup and steep for 5 to 7 minutes, then strain. Covering it keeps the aromatic oils in the cup instead of the air. Herbal teas don’t turn bitter the way black tea does, so steeping longer just makes them stronger.
- Chamomile: Use a generous amount. Weak chamomile tastes like hot water with a hint of hay.
- Peppermint: Strong and fast. Five minutes is plenty.
- Lavender: Go easy, about half a teaspoon of dried flowers per cup. Too much and it tastes like soap.
A few pairings that work:
- Chamomile with a little honey.
- Peppermint with a slice of lemon.
- Lavender with a drop of vanilla, or blended with chamomile.
Making Yerba Mate
In South America, mate is drunk from a gourd through a metal straw, and the gourd is often passed around a group. You can also just brew it in a French press, but the traditional way is easy enough. You’ll need:
- Loose leaf yerba mate
- A gourd or cup
- Filtered straw (bombilla)
- Hot water
Then:
- Fill the gourd: Fill it about two-thirds with the dry leaves.
- Add hot water: Use hot, not boiling, water (around 160-175°F). Boiling water makes mate bitter. Pour it in until it reaches the top.
- Insert the bombilla: Push the straw down to the bottom. Its filter end keeps the leaves out of your mouth.
- Drink and refill: Sip it down, then top up with more water. The same leaves last for many refills before the flavor fades.
Sharing works the same way: one person fills the gourd, drinks, refills it and passes it on.
Whisking Matcha
Matcha is whisked, not steeped. Sift about a teaspoon of powder into a bowl, add a few ounces of hot water and whisk until a fine foam forms on top. A bamboo whisk (chasen) does this best, but a small electric frother works too.
- Buy decent matcha. Cheap, dull-colored powder is usually harsh and bitter.
- Keep the water around 175°F. Boiling water brings out the bitterness.
- Whisk fast in a zigzag (an “M” or “W” shape) rather than in circles. That’s what builds the foam.
- Good matcha should look bright green and smooth, with no clumps at the bottom.
Creating Golden Milk
Golden milk takes about 15 minutes, most of it waiting.
Ingredients
- For one mug:
- 1 cup of milk (dairy or plant-based)
- 1 teaspoon of ground turmeric
- ½ teaspoon of ground cinnamon
- A pinch of ground black pepper
- Optional: a small piece of fresh ginger, grated, and honey or maple syrup for sweetness
- You can also buy pre-made golden milk powder, which just needs stirring into hot milk.
Preparation
- Heat the milk: Warm it in a saucepan over low heat. Don’t let it boil, or it’ll scorch and form a skin.
- Add the spices: Whisk in the turmeric, cinnamon, pepper and ginger. Turmeric clumps, so keep whisking.
- Simmer gently: Leave it on low for about 10 minutes so the spices infuse.
- Strain and serve: Pour through a fine sieve into a mug and sweeten to taste. Watch your countertop: turmeric stains.
Best Healthy Coffee Alternative
There’s no single best choice for everyone, but if you want something that actually tastes like coffee and has no caffeine, Teeccino is the one most people end up with.
Teeccino is a caffeine-free herbal coffee. It contains no coffee beans. The blends are made from roasted ingredients such as chicory root, carob, barley, dates and figs, ground to look and brew like coffee. There are plenty of flavors, from plain roasts to hazelnut and vanilla, and you can buy it ground for a coffee maker or in tea-style bags. The chicory adds inulin, a prebiotic fiber.
It’s also low in acid, so people with a sensitive stomach often handle it better than coffee. One caveat: blends that contain barley are not gluten-free, so check the label if that matters to you.
Tips for Choosing the Right Alternative
Consider Flavor Preferences
Start with what you like about coffee. If it’s the dark, bitter taste, go for roasted roots and grains. If it’s having something warm and comforting, a tea or latte will probably do. A few other things to think about:
- Bitterness: Chicory and dandelion root are bitter, often more than coffee. Carob and barley blends are smoother and sweeter.
- Flavored versions: Many herbal coffees come in vanilla, chocolate or spiced versions, which help if the plain ones taste too earthy.
- Milk: Most roasted alternatives taste much better with milk. If you drink coffee black, expect an adjustment period.
Caffeine Content
Decide whether you want no caffeine or just less. Herbal teas, golden milk, chicory and herbal coffees have none. Decaf has a little. Yerba mate and matcha have a fair amount, so they’re for cutting back, not quitting.
Nutritional Value
Don’t expect much nutrition from any brewed drink. A cup of anything steeped in water is mostly water. A few points are still worth knowing:
- Antioxidants: Chicory, dandelion and matcha all contain polyphenols. Matcha has more than steeped green tea because you’re drinking the ground leaf.
- Fiber: Chicory root is high in inulin, and some of it ends up in your cup.
- Milk-based drinks: Golden milk and lattes get most of their nutrition (protein, calcium) from the milk, not the spices or powders.
FAQs About Coffee Alternatives
Are Coffee Alternatives Healthier?
They can be, mainly because of what they don’t have. If caffeine gives you jitters or keeps you up, a caffeine-free alternative fixes that. Roasted herbal coffees are also lower in acid, which helps some people with heartburn. Beyond that, coffee itself has a decent health record for most people, so “healthier” depends on why you’re switching. And watch the extras: a sugary syrup-heavy latte isn’t healthier whatever it’s made from.
Can I Drink Coffee Alternatives Every Day?
Yes. Most caffeine-free alternatives are fine every day for healthy adults. Two things to keep an eye on:
- Caffeine: Matcha, yerba mate and chai still contain caffeine, so count them if you’re trying to cut back.
- Specific ingredients: Chicory and dandelion can upset sensitive stomachs, and some herbs interact with medications. If you’re pregnant or on medication, check with your doctor before drinking a lot of any herbal product.
Are Coffee Alternatives Suitable for Kids?
Some are. Skip anything with caffeine, which rules out matcha, yerba mate and chai. Good options for children:
- Golden Milk: Mild and sweet with a little honey. Go light on the pepper. (Don’t give honey to babies under one.)
- Herbal Teas: Chamomile and rooibos are mild and caffeine-free. Serve them warm, not hot, and keep them weak.
- Milk-Based Drinks: Warm milk or a plant milk such as oat or soy with cinnamon or cocoa. If you use a plant milk, choose a fortified one.
If your child has allergies or a health condition, check with your pediatrician first.
Conclusion
If you want to quit caffeine and still have something that tastes like coffee, start with a chicory-based herbal coffee like Teeccino, with milk. If you’re more attached to the ritual than the taste, herbal tea or golden milk will do the job. And if you only want to cut back, matcha or yerba mate gives you a smaller dose of caffeine in a different package. Give whichever you pick a week or two. Most of these taste better once you stop comparing them with coffee.


